AL MVP – This award is given to the American League’s most valuable player.
Brooks’ Pick: Byron Buxton, Minnesota Twins
Byron Buxton is perhaps the most talented player in baseball. His outfield defense and speed are arguably the best in the league, and he boasts huge power and an advanced approach at the plate. Buxton has every tool you could ask for in a player — except durability. Buxton’s last full season was in 2018, and he has seen back-to-back incredible campaigns derailed by knee injuries. Buxton was the MVP frontrunner through 61 games in 2021 before a season-ending injury, and last year he was on pace for 49 home runs before another surgery knocked him out for half the year. While it’s risky to bet on players as injury-prone as Buxton, there’s no doubt that he’s one of the sport’s very best when healthy. If he can stay healthy this year, the sky’s the limit.
Andrew’s Pick: Shohei Ohtani, Los Angeles Angels
Should Ohtani have won this award over Aaron Judge last year? Maybe. It took a historic hitting season from Judge to beat Ohtani out, but assuming Judge doesn’t leave the yard 62 times this year, Ohtani will win this award easily. Nobody out there is starting a game on the mound, while also hitting cleanup, and doing both at an elite level. The Los Angeles Angels won’t win a ton of games this year, but this isn’t the NBA where your team needs to be good for you to win MVP. As long as Ohtani performs anywhere close to how he performed last year, he walks away with this award easily, and sets himself up to sign the biggest contract in MLB history this offseason.
NL MVP – This award is given to the National League’s most valuable player.
Brooks’ Pick: Ronald Acuña Jr., Atlanta Braves
After an ACL tear sustained in 2021, Acuña Jr. was subdued during the 2022 season, where he saw his prodigious power limited. Acuña Jr. admitted that his knee was still bothering him last year, but he should be at full strength now. Watch out, because a full-strength Acuña Jr. is one of the most dangerous hitters in the league. Acuña Jr. is one of the few true five-tool players in today’s league. He’s an excellent hitter in every direction, his power is incredible, he’s fast, and he plays brilliant defense in right field. With his knee healthy again, Acuña Jr.’s power and speed will go back to being near the top of the MLB. A 30/30 or even a 40/40 season is well within reach for Acuña this year.While San Diego’s Juan Soto will undoubtedly challenge for this award, I expect Acuña Jr. to bring home the MVP in 2023.
Andrew’s Pick: Juan Soto, San Diego Padres
What many baseball fans have been waiting on for years will finally happen in 2023: perennial MVP Candidate Juan Soto will finally take home the award, and he will do it convincingly. After being traded from the Washington Nationals, who were bottom feeders in the National League, Soto will benefit from being in a powerhouse lineup in San Diego. More pitchers will be forced to throw him competitive pitches, as he got walked a ton in Washington since there were no other hitters in the lineup to score him. What will Soto do with more competitive pitches? One word: Rake. Last year, Soto was in the 85th percentile or higher for numerous hitting stats, like max exit velocity, hard hit percentage, barrel percentage, strikeout percentage (which means he did not strikeout often) and walk percentage (which means he walked often). He shows no signs of slowing down, as he is only 24 years old, and is approaching a contract year, meaning he has more to play for. While his outfield defense won’t carry him to this award, his bat will do him wonders, beating out candidates such as Trea Turner, Nolan Arenado, and Paul Goldschmidt.
AL Cy Young – This award is given to the best pitcher in the American League.
Brooks’ Pick: Shane McClanahan, Tampa Bay Rays
Last year, McClanahan broke out in the way most fans expected him to, posting a 2.54 ERA and displaying greatly improved command. McClanahan was actually the Cy Young frontrunner heading into the All-Star break, as he led the league with a 1.71 ERA and started the All-Star game for the American League. Unfortunately, McClanahan tailed off to end the year, lagging behind eventual winner Justin Verlander as the Rays dealt with widespread injury issues. Now, entering his age-26 season with a better defense behind him, McClanahan will dominate. McClanahan has always boasted electric stuff, with a high-90s fastball complemented by a deadly 90-mph slider, but his command over his pitches dictates how great he can be. His control has improved drastically since his rookie season, and a more consistent 2023 will see the lefty take home his first Cy Young. Luis Castillo and teammate Tyler Glasnow will definitely contend, but McClanahan is too filthy to be denied.
Andrew’s Pick: Luis Castillo, Seattle Mariners
In my eyes, there is absolutely no way Castillo doesn’t win this award. Castillo was pretty dominant last year, finishing with a 2.99 ERA, and an ERA+ of 130. He was traded at the deadline last season, moving from the Cincinnati Reds to the Seattle Mariners. 2023 will be his first full season with the Mariners, who are better than the Reds in almost every aspect of the game. Castillo looked great against a talented Guardians squad on Opening Day, so watch for him to continue this dominance all season long in Seattle, and establish himself as the no-doubt ace in a loaded Mariners rotation.
NL Cy Young – This award is given to the best pitcher in the National League.
Brooks’ Pick: Corbin Burnes, Milwaukee Brewers
Corbin Burnes’ 2019 season was one of the worst pitching seasons we’ve ever seen in the MLB. Coming out of the bullpen, Burnes posted a shocking 8.82 ERA, allowing 48 runs in 49 innings pitched. After that year, Burnes went into Milwaukee’s starting rotation and morphed into one of the most devastating pitching weapons in the league. Burnes has had a sub-3.00 ERA every year since then, taking home the 2021 Cy Young in dominant fashion. Burnes led the NL in strikeouts last year, and entering his age-28 season, there’s no reason why Burnes won’t be even more dominant this year. Burnes pairs a deadly cutter with a wipeout slider and a high-90s fastball, making him one of the best strikeout artists in the league. While Milwaukee has two other starters that could win this award with Brandon Woodruff and Freddy Peralta, Burnes is far and away the best of the bunch, and he will cruise to his second Cy Young in 2023.
Andrew’s Pick: Sandy Alcantara, Miami Marlins
Aside from Jacob deGrom, Sandy Alcantara may be one of the best pitchers I have ever watched pitch. Alcantara put the league on notice when he won the NL Cy Young award unanimously in 2022, and now Alcantara will look to cement himself as the best pitcher in the league outright. In terms of innings pitched, Alcantara is an absolute workhorse, who pitched a MLB high 228.2 innings in 2022, and was dominant while doing it, throwing to the tune of a 2.28 ERA. Batters simply could not hit Sandy in 2022 and what’s to say they will all the sudden find barrels this season? Sandy should coast past other Cy Young candidates such as Zac Gallen and Justin Verlander to win his second consecutive Cy Young in 2023.
AL Rookie Of The Year – This award is given to the American League’s best rookie. MLB rookies are required to have been on an active roster for less than 45 days, so a player that debuted at the end of last season can technically still be a rookie.
Brooks’ Pick: Anthony Volpe, New York Yankees
The AL Rookie of the Year race will likely come down to two shortstops: Baltimore’s Gunnar Henderson vs. New York’s Anthony Volpe. I’m going to go with Volpe here, as he is the more well-rounded player. While Volpe doesn’t have a major standout trait, there aren’t really many flaws in his game either – Volpe does everything well. This should make him incredibly pro-ready as a rookie, whereas Henderson may struggle early. In a media market as massive as New York, Volpe will get a massive boost in the news, especially if he is successful out of the gate. If he can get early success for the most famous and visible team in the league, it will be hard to pick against Volpe.
Andrew’s Pick: Masataka Yoshida, Boston Red Sox
Masataka Yoshida is a name to learn, ASAP. Most of us haven’t seen Yoshida play yet, as he is just coming to the MLB from Japan, but if there is anything you need to know it’s this: Yoshida can hit. In Japan last year, he had a slash line of .336/.449/.559, and had an OPS+ of 1.007. Those numbers are crazy high, and Yoshida would’ve had the highest batting average in the MLB last year if he was in the league. Yoshida’s lowest OPS was .856, which was in 2016, and his OPS has increased every year since. Assuming Yoshida keeps up with this trend and learns how to hit American pitching, he will win the AL rookie of the year in 2023.
NL Rookie of the Year – This award is given to the National League’s best rookie.
Brooks’ Pick: Corbin Carroll, Arizona Diamondbacks
Corbin Carroll has been one of the top prospects in baseball for a long time, and it’s easy to see why. He has excellent contact skills, adequate power, and good outfield defense. However, his calling card is his top-of-the-scale speed. Carroll is already the fastest player in the sport, as he led the MLB in sprint speed last year with a blistering 30.7 ft/sec. The increase in base size this year will make Carroll even more of a threat on the basepaths. In his 32-game audition at the end of the 2022 season, Carroll showed that he was more than ready for the show, posting a .260 batting average along with a .830 OPS (on-base plus slugging), which was 33% better than the league average. Carroll will pick up right where he left off in 2023, and his MLB-ready skillset should make him the clear Rookie of the Year and a 20-20 threat for years to come.
Andrew’s Pick: Corbin Carroll, Arizona Diamondbacks
Welcome to the majors, Corbin Carroll! While hardcore fans and MLB casuals alike begin to learn Carroll’s name, Carroll will be quick to wow them. Carroll is the fastest player in the league, period. If you don’t believe the numbers, head to Baseball Savant, a website loaded with MLB stats, race the top players for yourself, and watch Carroll win. He is fast. Carroll uses this immense speed on the base paths, but he also uses it in the outfield , where he is a plus defender. While the likes of Mets pitcher Kodai Senga and Cardinals outfielder Jordan Walker will challenge Carroll for this award, Carroll should take home the 2023 NL Rookie of the Year.